BMG [Release date 30.09.16]
To many Emerson, Lake & Palmer represented the worst excesses of prog rock – a genre that was destined to have its collective arse kicked in the late-1970s. This latest tranche of remasters does demonstrate why prog rock got bad press at the extreme end of the spectrum, with a band like ELP who were rumoured to have a roadie whose job was to transport and clean the gigantic £2000 Persian rug on which they stood when performing. Plus their keyboard player (RIP) shoved knives into his organ and had a spinning piano.
1972′s Trilogy is enhanced here with a bonus ‘alternate album’ which adds an alternate version of ‘From The Beginning’ and a live version of ‘Hoedown’. This latter piece was to become a firm live favourite whilst the former demonstrated that the band was not all bombast and bluster and could fashion an attractive four minute pop song.
This third studio album is a natural successor to ‘Tarkus’ and features the engaging two-part ‘The Endless Enigma’ although the band found it difficult to replicate the album live which led to a different recording approach for its follow-up. ****
Brain Salad Surgery is considered to be one of their most consistent albums and the only thing missing from this latest reissue is a facsimilie cut-out H.R. Giger sleeve. A bonus disc, mixed by Jakko M Jakszyk, brings the album into the modern idiom using alternate versions and different original mixes to fashion another ‘alternate album’.
A similar process has been carried out on Uriah Heep’s ‘Very ‘eavy Very ‘umble’ which is part of a similar BMG reissue series. Whether it enhances or detracts is left for the listener to decide, for this reviewer it smacks a little of wringing the last drop out of the vintage wine bottle. There are though excellent alternate takes on ‘Karn Evil 9 3rd Impression’ including the original backing track although the session outtake ‘Tiger In A Spotlight’ (which appeared on Works Volume 2) is omitted.
This disc did at least make me want to go in search of my original NME flexi disc version of album highlights, whilst realising it was jettisoned many years ago. This deluxe version, as with ‘Trilogy’, is essentially a reissue of 2014/5 releases. This was ELP at the height of their commercial and creative powers. ****1/2
By the way, this is the album that contains the four-part ‘Karn Evil 9′ that is perhaps best known to a certain generation as including one of “Fluff” Freeman’s radio sweepers Welcome back my friends to show that never ends… This piece gave the title to the third release in this batch of reissues, the 1974 live album.
Four albums in, the time was right to reflect their live performance on album and it is perhaps indicative that they included all but one song from ‘Brain Salad Surgery’. For trainspotters, the piece ‘Take A Pebble’ which appears twice includes the ‘Tiger In The Spotlight’ melody (see above) . ***1/2
These reissues are updated by Chris Welch’s liner notes, including new interview material, and are presented in attractive digi-packs. With Keith Emerson’s sad passing earlier this year, they provide excellent re-evaluation material or a starter for those who wish to steep themselves in a bit of unashamed prog excess. Don’t worry, we won’t tell.
Review by David Randall
David Randall presents ‘Assume The Position’ on Get Ready to ROCK! Radio every Sunday at 22:00 GMT.
Album review (Reissues 1)
Listen in to Get Ready to ROCK! Radio…
Click the appropriate icons at the top of the page.
Each week David Randall presents ‘New to GRTR!’ on Get Ready to ROCK! Radio, with the emphasis on independent artists and labels. During December he replays favourite tracks including power plays featured during the year. This show covers the period January-March and was first broadcast on 1 December 2019.
Power Plays w/c 25 November (Mon-Fri)
Throughout December we are featuring Best of 2019 selections from the GRTR! Reviewers.
Featured Albums w/c 25 November (Mon-Fri)
09:00-12:00 Melodic Rock Featured Albums of 2019
12:00-13:00 Melodic Hard Rock Featured Albums of 2019
14:00-16:00 Singer Songwriter Featured Albums of 2019
Albums That Time Forgot (Mon-Fri)
A selection of albums featured in 2019
Tweets by Get Ready to ROCK!