Album Review: RETURNED TO THE EARTH – Fall Of The Watcher

January 8th, 2023 by alanjones

Giant Electric Pea [Release date: 27.01.23]

Written and recorded through lockdown between 2019 and 2021, ‘Fall Of The Watcher’ is Returned To The Earth’s fourth foray into the studio.

Originally released in 2022 on BandCamp, Giant Electric Pea, the exemplary progressive rock label created by IQ’s Mike Holmes and Martin Orford with Thomas Waber (founder of Inside Out Music), obviously liked what they heard, signed the band and have re-released it with new packaging and, I think, a new running order.

It’s easy to see the attraction – RTTE epitomise the very ethos of the label – but I suspect they have signed perceived potential rather than the finished article here as ‘Fall Of The Watcher’, whilst a very good album, with exemplary playing throughout, just lacks that certain je ne sais quoi that turns a good album into a great album.

Robin Peachy, RTTE’s main-man, vocally sounds like a cross between IQ’s Peter Nicholls and musical maven Steven Wilson (Porcupine Tree, Blackfield, et al) – but vocally is where the similarity ends I’m afraid, with ‘Fall Of The Watcher’ being a bit too “safe” and the ‘wow’ quotient being at a premium.

Things get off to a good start with the classic prog lead-in of swirling keys on ‘April Sky’ but it’s not until the flanged guitar appears towards the end of the track that things pick up – in fact the album almost takes this as its starting gun.

‘Drowning’ is much more like it with its upbeat guitar and complementary keys and the title track takes things a notch higher with an ear-worm of a bass riff, a dreamy vocal juxtaposed with powerful riffage and an acoustic interlude replaced with searing fretwork. Shades of Porcupine Tree here and a definite highpoint.

Things take a downward turn though with ‘Lack Of Information’ (could be ‘Lack Of Excitement’) and ‘Sacrificed In Vain’s dirge-like tropes, although the latter is rescued to an extent by wonderful chiming guitar.

Closer ‘White Room’ is the most IQ-like track with swirling keys (RTTE like swirling keys) but it all ends up a being a bit too close to the Cocteau Twins for comfort.

The whole album is very pleasant on the ear but really needs an injection of adventure and an element of surprise. Perhaps signing for GEP will push RTTE to greater things – a listen to label-mates IQ would point the way forward.

Shows great promise – just needs that spark that all great prog bands have. ***

Review by Alan Jones

GRTR!@20 Primer: Progressive Rock

Featured Artist: JOSH TAERK

Since early 2020 Josh has been entertaining us with exclusive monthly live sessions, streamed via Facebook.
In 2023 he signed a recording deal with Sony in Canada and released a new single on 15 September.

Next session: Sunday 1 December

Check out videos here: https://www.facebook.com/getreadytorockradio

David Randall presents a weekly show on Get Ready to ROCK! Radio, Sundays at 22:00 GMT, repeated on Mondays and Fridays), when he invites listeners to ‘Assume The Position’. The show signposts forthcoming gigs and tours and latest additions at getreadytorock.com. First broadcast on 20 October 2024.

UK Blues Broadcaster of the Year (2020 and 2021 Finalist) Pete Feenstra presents his weekly Rock & Blues Show on Tuesday at 19:00 GMT as part of a five hour blues rock marathon “Tuesday is Bluesday at GRTR!”. The show is repeated on Wednesdays at 22:00, Fridays at 20:00). This show was first broadcast 22 October 2024.

How to Listen Live?

Click the programming image at the top of the page (top right of page if using desktop)

Listen via Windows Media Player. Click or tap here and “open file”
Listen via other media player (eg. VLC) Click or tap here and “open file”

Get Ready to ROCK! Radio is also in iTunes under Internet Radio/Classic Rock
Listen in via the Tunein app and search for “Get Ready to ROCK!” and save as favourite.

More information and links at our radio website where you can listen again to shows via the presenter pages: getreadytorockradio.com

Power Plays w/c 28 October 2024

THE RASMUS Rest In Pieces (Better Noise Music)
THE PLAGUE What Else Can I Do (FiXT)
STAR CIRCUS Turn The Tide (indie)
DEFENCES Breathe It In (Long Branch Records)

Featured Albums w/c 28 October 2024

09:00-12:00 The Best of 2003-2023 (Melodic Rock)
12:00-13:00 The Best of 2003-2023 (Melodic Hard Rock)
14:00-16:00 The Best of 2003-2023 (Singer Songwriter)